The shifting tides of academe: oscillation between hand and computer in architectural education
International Journal of Technology and Design Education
273 - 283
Item Usage Stats
MetadataShow full item record
There is a current vacillation in choosing hand or computer for design presentation in academia. Although the computer emerged as very powerful alternative presentation medium, it could not sweep away the hand totally. Believing that this vacillation cannot only be due to the positive and negative aspects of both media, we worked with a group of students in a design curriculum to observe the factors that affect their choice of medium for presenting design ideas. The students were required to use both media for the same task, subsequently their satisfaction and evaluation were examined through a questionnaire. Students acknowledged the positive aspects of both media, rather than accumulating on one side. Findings led us to concur that the constant oscillation of architecture between art and science penetrates down to the individual choice of presentation medium. We assert that the warmness of hand is not deserted as it contemplates the artistic essence, while the digital perfection of the computers flirt with science. The ever-attended, age-old question of architecture's being art and/or science occupies the architectural agenda at various levels. Both the polarizations and the reconciliations have theoretical, practical and educational consequences. This paper locates itself within this context and proposes a new framework for analyzing the impacts of this oscillation in design presentation, concluding that the future of presentation in education points to the coexistence of both media.
Computer aided design
Published Version (Please cite this version)https://doi.org/10.1007/s10798-005-5052-2
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
The virtual design studio on the cloud: a blended and distributed approach for technology-mediated design education Pektaş, Ş. T. (Taylor and Francis Ltd., 2015)The studio is widely accepted as the core in design education because it aims to integrate many curricular topics within its scope. However, learning environments in studio teaching have not been explored and exploited as ...
Cantimur, İnci (Bilkent University, 2009)Virtual worlds are being increasingly used in architectural education. This thesis aims at investigating the potentials of one of such virtual world, Second Life (SL), as a design platform by focusing on its specific ...
Bilda, Zafer (Bilkent University, 2001)Designers depend on representations to externalize their design thoughts. External representations are usually in the form of sketches (referred to as traditional media) in architectural design during the conceptual ...